If you buy a laptop online and switch it on to try it out, have you lost your right to cancel? Not simply by switching it on, held the Court of Appeal on 13 November 2026 in Dr Ebenezer Adodo v Argos Limited [2026] EWCA Civ 1462. Andrews LJ, with whom Foxton and King LJJ agreed, allowed Dr Adodo’s appeal and ordered Argos to refund the price of the laptop with interest (paras 8, 78–80). Booting up a computer and activating its preloaded operating system does not break a “sealed computer software” seal (paras 73–74).
What the case was about
On 31 August 2024 Dr Adodo ordered a Lenovo IdeaPad laptop, preloaded with Windows 11, for £379 on the Argos website, together with a mouse pad, using click and collect (para 2). At home he switched the laptop on and found compatibility problems with the software he used at work. On 5 September he took both items back, but Argos staff refused a refund because the box had been opened and the laptop turned on (para 3).
Dr Adodo sued in the county court on the small claims track, relying on the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, which let a consumer cancel a distance contract within 14 days without giving a reason (para 4). On a first appeal, the judge held that the contract was a distance contract and that Dr Adodo was entitled to a refund for the mouse pad (para 5). But he accepted Argos’ argument that switching the laptop on and activating Windows 11 broke a “digital seal”, so that the right to cancel was lost under Regulation 28(3)(b) (para 6). That exception applies to “a contract for the supply of … sealed computer software, if the goods become unsealed after delivery” (paras 1, 39).
What the Court of Appeal decided
The exception is read strictly. The Regulations implement an EU Directive aimed at a high level of consumer protection, and are now interpreted using ordinary domestic principles, with that purpose in mind (paras 9–10, 15). Following the CJEU in Slewo, exceptions to the right to cancel are construed strictly, because online buyers should be able to test goods as they could in a shop (para 54).
A laptop sale is not a contract for sealed software. One would not naturally describe buying a computer that happens to have an operating system preloaded as a contract for the supply of computer software, let alone sealed software. The software is incidental to the supply of the computer (paras 53, 74).
The purpose of the exception does not fit. The court held that the exception must be concerned with protecting intellectual property, mainly the risk that content is copied. A subsidiary concern, for recordings and some software such as games, is that buyers could otherwise treat the trader as a free lending library (paras 56–57). Neither concern justifies stopping a consumer from powering up a laptop and activating its operating system to test whether it works (para 60). Argos accepted that preventing activation was unlikely to protect anyone’s intellectual property (para 62).
The test. Regulation 28(3)(b) covers only contracts where (i) the recording or software is the specific object of the sale, and (ii) the medium carrying it is physically sealed in packaging that the consumer must open to get to the contents (para 73). The “seal” is the outer packaging, not “some notional internal digital barrier” broken when software is activated (para 74). Argos’ reading would have stripped consumers of the right to cancel almost any online purchase of a computer, phone or gadget with pre-installed software as soon as it was switched on (para 8).
Configuration and diminished value. The court did not consider that Dr Adodo had “configured” the software. Even if he had, the European Commission’s guidance envisages that the consumer keeps the right to cancel. The trader may recover the reasonable cost of reversing the configuration, if restoring the factory settings involves more than simply pressing a button. Argos made no attempt to prove any such cost (paras 70–71).
Why it matters
- Online buyers can test their devices. Switching on a laptop and running its operating system to check it works does not, by itself, end the 14-day right to cancel (paras 8, 77).
- The seal must be physical. The exception is aimed at sealed recordings and software on a tangible medium, such as boxed anti-virus programs, games or CDs, once the wrapper is opened (paras 52, 59–60, 73).
- Traders still have a remedy for excessive handling. Where a consumer handles goods beyond what is needed to establish their nature, characteristics and functioning, the trader may recover the reduction in value, up to the contract price (paras 37, 71).
- Information duties are no substitute. Telling a consumer how a computer is supposed to work is not the same as letting them test it (para 63).
- In our view, retailers whose returns policies refuse refunds simply because an electronic device has been switched on should review them in light of this decision. The win is all the more notable because Dr Adodo represented himself (para 68).
Free to search across 25 official UK databases — no account needed. Explore the authorities behind this case:
Read the full judgment: Dr Ebenezer Adodo v Argos Limited [2026] EWCA Civ 1462 (The National Archives).